Skip to content
April 15, 2009 / Kushal

A Duty to Vote?

So the charade continues. I saw this ad where a guy approaches a girl in the crowd and tells his minions to bring her tea to wake her up. She angrily responds saying she’s not asleep. The guy assumes a self-righteous reprimanding tone and says “it’s election day, if you’re not casting a vote, then you’re asleep.”

Why are people so hell bent on making total idiots out of themselves? If you know the political process, if you know what forms a good policy decision, if you know what sort of economic policies are good for the country, and if you know which of the candidates seems capable of making the right choices, then yes, you should go and cast a vote.

But what if you don’t know all of this? What if all your knowledge comes from things you’ve just heard from other people who, in turn, have heard it from someone else, and so on? What if you don’t know one damn thing about the past of the candidates running for office? Would it still be wise to go and just pick someone based on half-baked decisions just because everyone says it’s your duty to vote?

Carl Sagan said, “Where we have strong emotions, we’re liable to fool ourselves.” That’s exactly what’s happening here. Someone knew just how liable people are to fool themselves. All they had to do was fill us up with the hogwash of how our voice should be heard across the nation and that we can do it with our vote, and we’re sold. Most of us don’t even think twice about what the hell our voice — which we want to resonate across the nation — should say in the first place.

How many Indians have even read, let alone understood, the Constitution of India? How many people know even half of the policies our former ministers have implemented and the effects they had on our economy? Does an average man know anything about political process beyond the widely advertised Government bans on various things?

In fact, how many “youths” remember the structure of our government that we learned in “Civics” during our school days.

Here’s a simple test: what do you think of this statement, “everyone should have easy access to home loans regardless of their income status, and the government should support banks who do poor people a noble service by helping them buy a house for their families.”

If you agree with it, you’d be doing a greater service to your country — and humanity — by staying home on election day.


P. S.: One of my favorite columnists John Stossel has written an article on the same subject. Here’s the link in case you’re interested: http://www.creators.com/opinion/john-stossel/a-duty-not-to-vote.html

9 Comments

Leave a Comment
  1. Alex / Apr 15 2009 10:08 pm

    Well, the joke’s on the guy in the ad; he’s the one who’s asleep.

  2. Rakhi / Apr 15 2009 10:33 pm

    I really liked this post. I think what happens in India to those who are not “informed” is that they vote based on the publicity done by political parties or for that matter “my favorite actor/ actress is endorsing this party”. and in that situation actors like Govinda and smriti irani get elected. However, no body follows the work they do, besides their acting and films, once they are elected. Number of voters do not count. But those who vote honestly (without any bribes from political parties) and are “informed” about the constitution and politics.

  3. Kushal / Apr 16 2009 1:14 am

    Oh yes Alex, absolutely. And so are the people who like that ad (and believe me, there are many of them here who do)

  4. Kushal / Apr 16 2009 1:16 am

    You’re right Rakhi. That’s definitely one of the reasons why actors get elected. People here couldn’t care less about what the politician is actually going to do except repair some bad road or increase the water supply in their areas.

  5. Jayalakshmi / Apr 29 2009 4:23 am

    Change takes time.

    I feel by not voting, and keeping silent, we may be doing more disservice and indicate that we don’t care.

    From the last election to this, I find there are more questions being sked , parties are on the back foot , or are being defensive due to questions raised in the media, internet or other public fora.

    Yes political parties have thick hides, and will brush off questions this time.

    But , questions are being formed in the minds of common people more and more.
    Answers will have to be furnished, accountability will become an important issue.
    So we need to tell those netas , we are there, we are watching.

    Let everyone vote. It may bring about change, slowly.

  6. Kushal / Apr 29 2009 6:32 am

    Thanks for your comment Jayalakshmi.

    I’m not asking people to be silent, and I’m definitely not asking them to not vote. What I’m saying is that to be able to choose the right candidate you need to have the right amount of information. Unless someone has that, they should refrain from just casting a vote without full knowledge of what they’re doing. That would be like asking a lay man to perform surgery, the consequences of which will be disastrous. And that’s exactly what all the recent commercials about voting are encouraging people to do — to vote, regardless of what they know about the political process and the right candidates. That’s what this post is all about.

  7. Alex / Apr 29 2009 6:58 pm

    Maybe you ought to ask at least some people not to vote. What if there is no “right” candidate? What about those who are too stupid to understand what’s at stake in the political process? Not that they would listen. Of course they wouldn’t admit that they’re stupid.

  8. Jayalakshmi / Apr 30 2009 4:17 am

    thanks

    May be we need to wait for 49 O

    That may stop some people from contesting.

    I hope something good will evolve.

    God bless.

  9. Kushal / Apr 30 2009 4:36 pm

    I don’t know what 49 O is. Could you please elaborate?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.